may be Permelia Barnwhistle m 5/22/1841 Wood cty Oh
1880 census has this spelling of first name, and shows granddaughter named Gennie B Fancher b 1869 in Oh. also lists as Daniel O Blodgett.
in 1880 census living in Columbia Wa as a farmer
was in Columbia Wa in 1880 census
1850 and 1860 census indicate b 1843-1845